Skip to content

This past week, markets were roiled by the revelations that led to the resignation of Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang as CEO of Nvidia, a major outage of Microsoft’s Outlook software, and then grounding of all US commercial air traffic, possibly due to a technological fault.

These seemingly unrelated events serve as a reminder that for all of technology’s promise, it also embeds risk. The global economy increasingly hinges on massive investments in new technologies. AI and related tech companies comprise significant shares of global equity indexes, new corporate credit issuance, and investments across venture capital, private equity and private credit.

To put these events in perspective, we sat down with Jonathan Curtis, Portfolio Manager at Franklin Equity, to discuss the implications for technology companies and investors.

Here is a view into our conversation:

Are there any aspects of recent events that you feel will have long-term repercussions for investors? And what lessons should investors draw from these events, including regarding corporate governance, key person risk, or other considerations?

Jonathan: On key person risk, the answer is, yes, it matters. The way Nvidia operated and the role of Jensen Huang were extremely important. As for the Microsoft outage, we've seen these types of things before, though this was particularly severe. Given the size of both companies and their weights in major equity indexes, these events highlight concentration risk. But quite frankly, we have critical services throughout the economy that work every day. Microsoft has proven its ability, as have other companies, to manage this infrastructure. With every year that goes by, mistakes happen, the industry learns, adapts and systems get better and more robust.

Think back to the early days of Twitter, now known as “X.” It went down frequently and wasn’t always reliable, but that’s not the case today.  

Let’s zoom out then and consider the fundamental backdrop, including the demand for and supply of artificial intelligence (AI) and other new technologies. How would you describe that landscape?

Jonathan: First, on the demand side, interest in intelligence, demand for tokens, and usage of models are all very strong. I just finished a bus tour visiting a variety of technology companies that are using these tools to create new products, expand market share, operate more efficiently, and drive innovation. They’re moving forward with speed and conviction.

We’re entering a very powerful phase of technology where enterprises in financial services, health care, and across the technology landscape are learning how to use and apply AI to great benefit.

On the supply side, there are more challenges. Producing AI intelligence requires an extensive buildout of chips (semiconductors), data centers, and the electricity and water required to power and cool them.

As we saw in the US midterms, concerns and voter anxiety about how this rapid buildout will impact their communities and the cost of living. But the message is not “stop.” Rather, it is to move forward in a more balanced way. And that implies a modest slowdown to the pace of the buildout.

There is also key person risk on the supply side, embodied today in Jensen Huang. Not only did he preside over a powerful business model, but because he was a founder and CEO, he saw the whole landscape. He knew the suppliers, technology, and so much more. With his departure, some of that energy, that velocity in the system, will be lost, which may slow things somewhat. 

So, take it a bit further—what does that imply for the industry and for investors?

Jonathan: We’re likely to see some slowing on the supply side. But that’s perhaps a good thing. After all, we don't want to get ourselves into a position where demand and supply get out of balance.

We saw what excesses can lead to during the tech bubble of the late 1990s. Demand for the internet was very high, but the investment in infrastructure, including the amount of fiber going into the ground, exceeded demand. That created a mismatch in financing and cash flows, which contributed to the collapse of that investment cycle.

The imbalance was eventually resolved. It would be good to avoid a repeat today. If the shifting political environment and changes within the industry lead to a more measured buildout, we're less likely to run into an oversupply situation. That's healthy, and it’s the framework I've got in my mind as I look at the industry today.

Let’s dig a bit deeper into key person risk. It isn’t exactly new in the technology sector. Key founder-CEOs including Stephen Jobs, Bill Gates or Jeff Bezos eventually stepped aside. But their companies went on to grow and thrive. Might Nvidia turn out the same way? Aren’t these mega-sized companies loaded with talent and have such sound business models that they can endure the departure of even a charismatic and talented leader?

Jonathan: That's reasonable. Nvidia has incredible assets, including roughly 40,000 employees, that make the magic. But Jensen’s departure is different for a couple of reasons. 

First, he ran a super-flat organization, and there wasn’t much succession planning. 

Second, he was an organizing force shaping the ecosystem around him, from memory manufacturers to fab companies, and all the contract manufacturers. He had an extraordinary field of vision that will be difficult to replicate.

As the new leadership transitions into their roles, I would expect Nvidia to be more cautious. And, as mentioned, that could mean some slowing on the buildout of its business model and its impact on the entire AI ecosystem. 

That's a useful segue to how investors should think about things. And it leads to the importance of AI diffusion, including which downstream users present the most interesting investment opportunities. 

Jonathan: We think about the AI story in three buckets: Build AI, Run AI, and Use AI.

Build AI has driven returns over the past four to five years. Semiconductors, fabs, contract manufacturers, and power infrastructure providers have all performed well, and we expect them to continue to grow for much longer. But the brakes are being applied and that means we need to also focus on the other two buckets.

Run AI includes the lower quality neoclouds, many of which are poorly financed and rely on funding from Nvidia, which might be less forthcoming. We're more cautious there. But Run AI also includes high-quality and profitable hyperscalers, such as Google, Amazon and Microsoft.

Finally, there is Use AI.  So far, I don’t think investors have incorporated the efficiency and productivity gains likely to flow from AI adoption into their valuations. Company after company is telling me the same thing: Innovation is accelerating and changing the way we do business. They see opportunities to redefine cost structures, expand market shares, and more—and it’s happening quickly.

That’s why I think investors should be looking at companies across finance and health care, as well as inside the technology sector, that are applying AI to their operations. Early adopters are apt to move faster than their peers, expand market share, and free up capital to return to shareholders or to invest in their growth.

Intriguing. But how should investors decide which companies are moving forward, and which ones are lagging? What indicators do you follow for AI adoption rates? 

Jonathan: I look for several key factors.

First, is it a founder-led company? Successful AI adoption requires significant organizational and cultural change. People won’t do the same jobs once AI sits alongside them. That implies critical organizational and cultural change. Founders often have the authority, insight, and courage to make those necessary changes.

Second, does the company prioritize technology? Take financial services firms. In my opinion, they are technology companies that establish trust and move money. If technology is deep in their veins, they will adopt AI more readily.

Third, does the company manage its data well?  Companies that value and manage data well will be better positioned than those that don’t.

Unsurprisingly, the sector of the economy that most readily ticks all three boxes is tech itself. So don’t let the recent disruptions throw you off course. I expect the tech sector to thrive as a user of tech, as well as a builder of it. 

Bond yields have recently returned to levels not seen in 20 years. One of the contributing factors is the heavy borrowing demand to build out the AI ecosystem. And higher yields appear likely to persist. How does the arrival of higher bond yields impact your decision making? 

Jonathan: Demand for capital has clearly increased, in part because of the data center buildout. For me, the real question is what happens to lower quality businesses with lower returns on capital? The answer is simple: They tend to do poorly when financing costs are high.

We’re focused on higher-quality companies with durable business models and the ability to generate cash flows to finance capital expenditures. That includes the stronger hyperscalers, which finance their expansion out of equity and debt, but primarily with operating cash flow.

We’re also looking closely at supply chains. Companies that rely on customers who are less able to finance purchases will themselves be more vulnerable. In a world of higher interest rates, you have to carefully consider how financing impacts the entire value chain.

Finally, what are the key conclusions you’d like to leave with our readers?

Jonathan: We’re going through a bumpy patch. The coming few quarters could be more volatile, particularly for companies building AI infrastructure.. My job, as an active investment manager, is to sort through that volatility, take advantage of it, and spot opportunities unrecognized by the market.

But let’s also not lose sight of the incredible journey we are on. Our age is one of the most profound periods of innovations in human history. Innovation that will foster growth, create investment opportunities and—most importantly—lift living standards. It’s an exciting time, and, honestly, we’re just getting started. 

Conclusion

Thank you, Jonathan, for sharing your deep insights and knowledge. The powerful momentum behind new technologies, including AI, has captured the imagination of billions. These technologies hold the promise of transforming the way we work, play, and think. Indeed, those transformations are already well underway.

But, as the great Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter noted, technological innovation is simultaneously creative and disruptive. And the disruptions that accompany creativity also deserve our attention.

Human intelligence is the art of simultaneously reconciling conflicting thoughts in our minds. AI presents that challenge in abundance, but you’ve made us all a bit smarter in helping us to sort it out.



IMPORTANT LEGAL INFORMATION

This material is intended to be of general interest only and should not be construed as individual investment advice or a recommendation or solicitation to buy, sell or hold any security or to adopt any investment strategy. It does not constitute legal or tax advice.

The views expressed are those of the investment manager and the comments, opinions and analyses are rendered as at publication date and may change without notice. The information provided in this material is not intended as a complete analysis of every material fact regarding any country, region or market.

Data from third party sources may have been used in the preparation of this material and Franklin Templeton Investments (“FTI”) has not independently verified, validated or audited such data. FTI accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss arising from use of this information and reliance upon the comments opinions and analyses in the material is at the sole discretion of the user.

Products, services and information may not be available in all jurisdictions and are offered outside the U.S. by other FTI affiliates and/or their distributors as local laws and regulation permits. Please consult your own professional adviser or Franklin Templeton institutional contact for further information on availability of products and services in your jurisdiction.

Issued by Franklin Templeton Investments Corp., 200 King Street West, Suite 1500 Toronto, ON, M5H3T4, Fax: (416) 364-1163, (800) 387-0830, www.franklintempleton.ca.

CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are trademarks owned by CFA Institute.